Download Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical by Sean Creaven PDF

By Sean Creaven

ISBN-10: 0415524040

ISBN-13: 9780415524049

The argument offered during this booklet is that the hot ‘spiritual’ trajectory of Roy Bhaskar’s paintings, upon which he first embarked with the e-book of his From East to West, undermines the basic achievements of his prior paintings. the matter with Bhaskar’s new philosophical procedure (Transcendental Dialectical severe Realism or just Meta-Reality), from the critical-realist Marxist viewpoint counseled right here, is that it marks either a departure from and a negation of the sooner issues of Bhaskar to advance a realist philosophy of technology and under-labour for an emancipatory materialist socio-historical technology. The end-result is a meta-philosophy that's irrealist, speculative, under-theorized, internally self-contradictory, and which can't offer philosophical tips to liberatory social practices. towards theist ontological logics extra ordinarily (including the far more rational theism provided through Margaret Archer, Andrew Collier and Doug Porpora), the argument of this e-book is that the earth-bound materialist dialectics of the classical Marxist culture, and the naturalistic humanism those dialectics under-labour at the terrain of socio-historical being, supply a way more promising future of severe realist idea and for liberatory politics and ethics.

Show description

Read or Download Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical Theory PDF

Best eastern books

Shentong and Rangtong: Two Views of Emptiness

The Mahayana direction of Buddhism calls for the advance of wast loving-kindness and compassion. the basis for constructing neutral compassion for all sentient beings relies on realizing the vacancy of self and the vacancy of phenomena. In Shentong and Rangtong Thrangu Rinpoche starts with a lucid description of the 4 significant colleges of Buddhism and their tenents.

Mortality in Traditional Chinese Thought

A wide-ranging exploration of conventional chinese language perspectives of mortality.

Writing As Enlightenment: Buddhist American Literature into the Twenty-first Century

Explores the superiority of Buddhist rules in American literature because the Seventies.

Extra resources for Against the Spiritual Turn: Marxism, Realism, and Critical Theory

Sample text

Dualism as ontology consists of the view that: (1) matter and mind are distinct substances, each in possession of a unique essence or essences, following their own laws; and (2) that any attempt at the explanatory reduction of one to the other must be considered foul play, in the sense of illegitimate and impossible. All that we can say, argues the dualist, is that there is both mind and matter in the cosmos. Mind might be the product of matter, or vice versa, but we cannot establish which (mind or matter) is ontologically foundational.

Since Hartwig’s realist agnosticism (which allows the rational assertability of metaphysical idealism) rests its case on the impossible ideal of infallible knowledge,49 and since this realist agnosticism obviously stands or falls with the defensibility or otherwise of ontological idealism, this gives us ‘good enough’ (albeit fallible) reasons for accepting a thoroughgoing materialism as the ontological foundation of critical social theory and politics. So the argument of this book is an attempt to substantiate the positive account of realist dialectical materialism outlined in my previous book Emergentist Marxism: Dialectical Philosophy and Social Theory.

The new Bhaskarian system is, I wish to argue, a departure from key tenets of CR, and it is also internally incoherent and undertheorized in crucial areas. 45 These problems undercut the ontological grounding of TDCR’s moral realism and divest emancipatory social struggles of philosophical bearings or guidance. Despite the author’s intentions, I agree with the critics that the central theistic or idealistic ontological theme of TDCR — the spiritualization of reality — make it incompatible with emancipatory politics and social theory, despite its contrary intentions.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.54 of 5 – based on 19 votes